Giving and Getting Critique
As part of our monthly meetings, we take time to critique each other's in-progress manuscripts. Members are encouraged to bring up to five double-spaced pages to read aloud to attending members to get their input.
For most writers, feedback is crucial, but it can be painful. It can be hard to hear someone tell you your masterpiece needs tweaking. For those who choose to participate, we have a few tips to keep in mind:
When we are giving critique:
When you are being critiqued:
Note:
Anyone attending their free meetings prior to joining is invited to provide critique to other members, but will not be eligible for their work to be critiqued at that time. Writers who are new to critique may not be comfortable hearing criticism of their work, so this policy allows potential members to see how critique works and get used to the idea. Once you are a paid member of the chapter, bring your five pages to the next meeting.
Tip:
When time or distance does not allow you to attend a regular critique group, we recommend “Becoming Your Own Critique Partner” an EPPIE-winning resource from Janet Lane Walters and Jane Toombs.
As part of our monthly meetings, we take time to critique each other's in-progress manuscripts. Members are encouraged to bring up to five double-spaced pages to read aloud to attending members to get their input.
For most writers, feedback is crucial, but it can be painful. It can be hard to hear someone tell you your masterpiece needs tweaking. For those who choose to participate, we have a few tips to keep in mind:
When we are giving critique:
- We always start with what we liked about the story. Every story has value and we reinforce that.
- We are diplomatic at all times. Not all people are at the same level in their writing.
- We strive to explain why we think the scene didn’t work and offer a suggestion on how to improve it.
When you are being critiqued:
- It’s not personal. It is meant to help you be a better writer. This of critique as a "risk-free" zone where you can see what other writers think.
- Remember, critiquing is subjective and only one person’s opinion.
- You are welcome to explain what you were trying to do, but don't argue or defend the work. You don’t have to change it if you are happy with the way it is written.
- That said, if more than three people make the same comment, it's a good idea to reconsider your approach.
- In the end, it is still your story, so your decision is final.
Note:
Anyone attending their free meetings prior to joining is invited to provide critique to other members, but will not be eligible for their work to be critiqued at that time. Writers who are new to critique may not be comfortable hearing criticism of their work, so this policy allows potential members to see how critique works and get used to the idea. Once you are a paid member of the chapter, bring your five pages to the next meeting.
Tip:
When time or distance does not allow you to attend a regular critique group, we recommend “Becoming Your Own Critique Partner” an EPPIE-winning resource from Janet Lane Walters and Jane Toombs.